| Cast |
Russell Crowe, Paul Bettany, James D'Arcy, Edward Woodall, Chris Larkin, Max Pirkis, Jack Randall |
| Director |
Peter Weir |
| Screenplay | Peter Weir, John Collee, from the novels by Patrick O'Brian |
| Music | Klaus Badelt, Iva Davies, Christopher Gordon, Richard Tognetti, Brian Tyler |
| Cinematography | Russell Boyd |
| Sound formats | Dolby Digital, Sony Dynamic Digital Sound, DTS |
| Made in | 2003 |
| Produced by | 20th Century Fox, Miramax Films, Universal Pictures, Samuel Goldwyn Films |
| Scale (Max) | 20 |  |
What the Critics say | ||
| The Moviesite Ian Douglas | 10 |  |
| Cape Argus Derek Wilson | 10 | |
| The Cape Times Sergio Ben | 15 |  |
| The Star Tanya Farber | 16 | |
| Die Burger Mariana Malan | 15 | |
| Sunday Times Barry Ronge | 20 | |
| eye Weekly Catherine Tunnacliffe | 15 | |
| Box Office Wade Major | 18 | |
| ReelViews James Berardinelli | 15 | |
| Chicago Sunday Times Roger Ebert | 20 | |
What the People say | ||
| Internet 1693 Netizens | 15 | |
Average .. 77% | 15 | |
| Scale (Max) | 20 | |
| Barbara Nuernberger (51) | 18 | |
| Aruana Zeelie (35) | 16 | |
Average .. 85% | 17 | |
It was a combination of several Standard Storylines — the cop-buddy movie, the road movie, the slice-of-life movie. Road movies and Slice-of-Life generally bore me, for some reason.
At times Crowe was using mannerisms from Beautiful Mind. Paul Bettany was very good as usual (Best Supporting Actor coming?), he seems to have fattened up quite a bit from Beautiful Mind and a Knight's Tale.
Certain plot points were way too obvious (which I obviously can't name), but I sat there just waiting for them to happen.
I enjoyed the odd moments of humour, even tho they were sometimes at points you would not expect them, like the Doc operating on himself...
I often struggled to follow the dialogue, not sure if it was the accents or just rushed uttering or background noise.
The Galopagos look like a good place to visit..
Barbara Nuernberger (51): I beg to differ with Ian Douglas: This is a movie for all educated romantic souls, male or female —
it contains beautiful cinematography, which shows the grand old sailing ships in all their magnificence, has good dialogue
(in impeccable English!) and features a very goodlooking masculine romantic hero (Crowe) who alone is worth watching and listening
to (voice like Richard Burton's) — at least to the more mature, (again, educated) female audience! I enjoyed
it from start to finish, except for a little too much blood and gore in the last battle scene. And what a nice, ironic (and humorous) ending!
Aruana Zeelie (35): I just adored this film. I have never read any of the Patrick O'Brian books, but M & C is apparently a mix of
the first book and the 10th book (there are 20 books in total). Miramax and Fox is (was) hoping to make this a franchise,
but I can't see that happening as the subject matter is not to everyone's taste. My cousin, who lives in the
States, also went to see it this weekend and she just did not like it — at all. Worldwide, the critics love this film
(our own Barry Ronge too). But unfortunately it is the audience that dictates if this movie will sink or swim (pardon the pun).